Showing posts with label for-profit healthcare. Show all posts
Showing posts with label for-profit healthcare. Show all posts
29 June 2011
More Docs Reject Privately Insured Patients!
A study expecting to find even fewer doctors willing to accept new Medicare patients found, sure enough, a modest drop in that percentage. But the shocker was a far steeper decline for doctors willing to accept privately insured patients.
The study shows 93.3 percent of doctors accepting insurance for payment in 2005, and 87.8 accepting insurance in 2008.
The drop for those accepting Medicare coverage during the same time was 95.5 percent down to 92.9 percent. Not the huge difference the right-wing media has been harping about - and they seem to have missed completely the fact that some doctors turn away patients wanting to pay with private insurance.
I first heard of this a few years ago with a doctor in Fort Collins, Colo., who wouldn't accept private insurance. He said he did so so he could practice medicine instead of argue with bureaucrats whose primary concern was profit, not patients. The insurance companies also didn't pay him enough - and he's a family doctor, not a country-club suburban specialist.
Dr. Tara Bishop's study was in the 27 June 2011 Archives of Internal Medicine. She's assistant professor of public health at Weill Cornell Medical College and practices at New York-Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical Center. Dr. Bishop is concerned that the growing numbers of physicians saying no thanks to insurance companies could bollocks up President Obama's reform - which depends on everyone buying private health insurance from this deadly industry.
It's one more reason to simply expand Medicare to cover everyone.
There are economic sectors where the free market delivers most effectively, no doubt. Manufacturing computers and running casinos come to mind. Other tasks - like covering the cost of health care, fighting fires, policing our communities, educating all the children - societies that tax themselves to provide those services for all come out ahead.
Pretty simple. You want the Pakistan model or Paris?
The study shows 93.3 percent of doctors accepting insurance for payment in 2005, and 87.8 accepting insurance in 2008.
The drop for those accepting Medicare coverage during the same time was 95.5 percent down to 92.9 percent. Not the huge difference the right-wing media has been harping about - and they seem to have missed completely the fact that some doctors turn away patients wanting to pay with private insurance.
I first heard of this a few years ago with a doctor in Fort Collins, Colo., who wouldn't accept private insurance. He said he did so so he could practice medicine instead of argue with bureaucrats whose primary concern was profit, not patients. The insurance companies also didn't pay him enough - and he's a family doctor, not a country-club suburban specialist.
Dr. Tara Bishop's study was in the 27 June 2011 Archives of Internal Medicine. She's assistant professor of public health at Weill Cornell Medical College and practices at New York-Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical Center. Dr. Bishop is concerned that the growing numbers of physicians saying no thanks to insurance companies could bollocks up President Obama's reform - which depends on everyone buying private health insurance from this deadly industry.
It's one more reason to simply expand Medicare to cover everyone.
There are economic sectors where the free market delivers most effectively, no doubt. Manufacturing computers and running casinos come to mind. Other tasks - like covering the cost of health care, fighting fires, policing our communities, educating all the children - societies that tax themselves to provide those services for all come out ahead.
Pretty simple. You want the Pakistan model or Paris?
02 March 2008
Your premiums pay for their lobbying
This came from Colorado State Rep. Morgan Carroll's office:POLICY CORNER
THE COST OF HEALTH CARE - LOBBYING IN HEALTH CARE
From 1998 - 2007 here’s how much the following industries spent on lobbying activities nationally:
- Insurance Industry spent $1,008,474,967 on lobbying
- Pharmaceutical Industry spent $1,316,714,703 on Lobbying
- Hospital / Nursing Home Industry spent $563,926,474 on Lobbying
- Health Professionals spent $531,096,203 on Lobbying
*SOURCE: Open Secrets.org
*SOURCE: Kaiser Family Foundation
Rep. Carroll notes that the consumer is ultimately footing a big bill for lobbying activities that are not always in their best interests.
24 January 2008
Sarkisyans: Insurance Is Not Healthcare
The California Nurses report that the Sarkisyans testified yesterday against Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's ABX1.1 mandates bill. After their insured, 17-year-old daughter was denied a transplant, it's the Sarkisyans' experience that insurance isn't the same thing as health care. How many of us must lose loved ones before this murderous industry is stopped?
How many families must become activists before our neighbors see that it could be them next time -- and act upon that understanding?
I've become a skipping dvd on this issue. The idea that forcing people to pay for-profit insurance companies is part of a solution to our health care crisis is like thinking that forcing shopkeepers to pay protection money to the Mafia is a solution to a crime wave. Which is what the health insurance industry is. A legalized crime wave.
Thank you to the Sarkisyans for taking their anger and grief and using it for good. It would be easier, and possibly more mentally healthy, to just forget about it. But how to save other 17-year-olds from the same fate, then? Thank you to the Sarkisyans.
Labels:
for-profit healthcare,
mandates,
Nataline Sarkisyan
16 January 2008
Health Insurance to Africa
Sound familiar?
For decades now the World Bank and IMF -- a bit like loan sharks in poor neighborhoods -- have held out fat loans for poor countries. The price for accepting those loans was accepting neoliberal ideology, and privatizing public services.
The loans also weren't usually tracked very carefully, so that they became a corrupting influence for government officials who became fat and retired to Switzerland on them.
So government services were cut, including health care. The money was ineffeciently spent, and then the loans came due -- forcing a further cut in social services. Including health.
And now a German professor has a research project going for how "access to proper insurance for all can be reached successfully" -- through micro-insurance. Same as we have here!
All according to plan.
Private insurance products hardly exist for the rural and urban poor and in cases where they do exist they are not affordable for them. Public Social Insurance Services are mostly insufficient and exclude people working in the informal sector. Nine out of ten people in Sub-Sahara Africa therefore do not have any access to health or accident insurance. They have to pay tremendously high fees for treatment, medical care and hospitalisation out of pocket. Especially those people living below the poverty line (more than 40% in Sub-Saharan Africa) have to take out loans, dissolve their savings or sell essential resources to pay for their treatment. Therefore, many are not in the position to make use of the required services at all. In fact, many people fall into poverty due to illness and treatment costs.
For decades now the World Bank and IMF -- a bit like loan sharks in poor neighborhoods -- have held out fat loans for poor countries. The price for accepting those loans was accepting neoliberal ideology, and privatizing public services.
The loans also weren't usually tracked very carefully, so that they became a corrupting influence for government officials who became fat and retired to Switzerland on them.
So government services were cut, including health care. The money was ineffeciently spent, and then the loans came due -- forcing a further cut in social services. Including health.
And now a German professor has a research project going for how "access to proper insurance for all can be reached successfully" -- through micro-insurance. Same as we have here!
All according to plan.
13 January 2008
Ezra's vision of health care
Ezra Klein spells out his vision of the best health care system possible in this imperfect world:
... a substantially public health care system in which government provides a guarantee of basic services, heavily regulated private insurers fight to compete against the basic plan, and somewhat less regulated private insurers compete with a public insurer to provide supplementary coverage to those who can afford it (those who cannot would be subsidized into the public insurer). ... all this because ... the profit motive is largely pernicious in the delivery of heath care, but nevertheless ... fears ... "no exit," ... it's possible insurers will come up with good ideas that it's worth forcing government to adapt against .... folks should be able to spend as much money on health care as they please -- health care should have a floor, but not a ceiling.
06 January 2008
Republican candidates talk health care

Republican talking points on health care as displayed at the New Hampshire debate last night:
(List points and discuss which elements are correct, which need rebuttal. Test Monday!)
DR. TIM JOHNSON, ABC MEDICAL EDITOR: In general, Republicans have criticized Democratic proposals for health care reform as radical expansions of the federal government's role. But many health care experts say that it is actually the Republicans' emphasis on individuals buying their own policies versus getting their insurance through employers that is a more radical change. And it raises concerns. Individual policies can be more expensive for the same coverage because of administrative overhead and sales costs.
Group policies like those provided by employers can bargain with providers for lower costs and do a better job of monitoring quality. Medical professionals caution that individual insurance may sound good on paper but it usually turns out to be very difficult for people, on their own, to find quality policies at the right cost.
GIBSON: ... We're the only industrialized nation in the world that doesn't insure all of our citizens. If we can afford a trillion-dollar war in Iraq, why can't we afford medical insurance for everybody?
GIULIANI: The reality is that, with all of its infirmities and difficulties, we have the best health care system in the world. And it may be because we have a system that still is, if not wholly, at least in large part still private.
To go in the direction that the Democrats want to go, much more government care, much more government medicine, socialized medicine, is going to mean a deteriorated state of medicine in this country. I mean, I said, jokingly, in one debate, if we go in the direction of socialized medicine, where will Canadians come for health care?
GIBSON: But do you all agree that we have the best health care system in the world?
MCCAIN: Now, tell me when people get sick where they come to to get health care...
GIULIANI: Charlie, that doesn't mean it shouldn't be improved. And I think that the notion of people buying their own private health insurance is a very good one, so long as a lot of them do it. Only 17 million Americans right now buy their own health insurance. If 50 million Americans were buying their own health insurance, because it would be just as tax advantageous to do it that way, and we had a health savings account, people -- economists believe there'd be a 30 percent to 50 percent reduction in the cost of health insurance, and quality would come up. The only thing that reduces cost and increases quality is a significant, dramatic, large consumer market, not government control.
GIBSON: You all have proposed free market, consumer-purchased insurance. And you all talk about giving tax deductions for buying insurance. Let me do a little math. The average family employer-provided insurance, when the company's buying, it's $13,000 a family. Now, you talked about a $15,000 to $20,000 deduction -- right? -- for people buying their own insurance. If you take a median-income family of $62,000 in this country, you've just saved them $3,000 on their taxes. That doesn't come close to buying an insurance policy.
MCCAIN: Sure. And next year, if you continue 10 percent inflation associated with it, it'll be even further away. And the next year after that. Because the problem with health care in America, it's not the quality. It is the inflation. And in all due respect to your expert that we just saw, he's talking about the wrong aspect of this issue. The right aspect of this issue is inflation, if we could get it under control and get it reduced so that health care costs are reasonable in America, then those people will be able to afford it... But we have to make the recipient of the health care more responsible. We have to have outcome-based results for health care. We have to emphasize wellness and fitness. One of the most disturbing things in America is the increase in diabetes, obesity and high blood pressure amongst younger Americans. So we have to award wellness and fitness...
But, again, you made a statement about European nations, they all get health care. Well, some people here in New Hampshire have been to Canada. I don't think they want that system.
ROMNEY: ... [after boasting about the Mass. plan] And where the doctor -- good doctor was wrong is that it's true the insurance companies don't want to sell policies to one person at a time. It's expensive. We established what we called a connector, a place where individuals could go to buy policies from any company, and that connector would in turn send their premiums on to those companies. So the economics of scale existed. And as a result of what we did, the premiums for health insurance for an individual buying insurance went from $350 a month to $180 a month, with lower deductibles and now with prescription drugs.
We don't have to have government take over health care to get everybody insured. That's what the Democrats keep on hanging out there. The truth is, we can get everybody insured in a free market way. We don't need Hillary-care or socialized medicine.
PAUL: Charlie, you really answered the question -- you answered it in your question, because you said, "How can we afford a trillion- dollar war and we can't afford health care?" Well, that's the reason. The resources are going overseas. We're fighting a trillion- dollar war and we shouldn't be doing it. Those resources should be spent back here at home. There is an inflationary factor. We can't afford it. We do have good medical care, but the costs are so high now that our people in this country are actually going to India and getting their heart surgery done. They pay the plane ticket, the hospital and the hotel and they get it for half-price.
So it's inflation, but if you don't understand how inflation comes, we can't solve this problem. It comes from deficit financing with this war-mongering foreign policy we have. We run up the deficits. We tax. We borrow. We borrow from the Chinese. We can't borrow enough. Then what do we do? We print the money, and then you wonder where the inflation comes. The value of the dollar is down and the prices go up, where the government gets involved in certain things like housing or medical care or education, prices are skyrocketing. So you have to deal with the monetary issue to solve the problem of the medical issue.
THOMPSON: Ahem. ... So if we would stop printing so much money, we could get out of the war and provide health care to everybody.
We've got the best health care in the world. It costs more than it should. We can either go one of two ways. We can let the government take it over, and that'll lower costs, like they do in other countries. We will also sacrifice care, which nobody wants to do -- we're not going to do, in this country.
Or we can make the markets work more efficiently. There are a lot of components to that. Part of that is not just giving a tax break to the individual. That's part of it. But it's also putting them in a position to get the best prices for the care they're getting. We do that in every other aspect of our life. That's what keeps prices as low as they are. I mean, if the consumer had no concept of what the product was costing and did no shopping for it, when you could get an MRI here for one price or over here for half the price, you don't even know that to make the choice. It wouldn't work at all. So you can do that. You can open up these markets so a person can buy their insurance from all over the country. We've got various state regulations now, that, as a practical matter, prohibit that. Make the markets work.
But we're never -- let's be honest with the people. We're probably never -- if you lower costs, more people who want insurance will be able to afford it. We're probably never going to achieve total coverage. A good number of the people who are uninsured can afford it and choose not to do so. A good number of people who are eligible for government assistance, and choose -- can manage and choose not to.
GIBSON: But Government Romney's system has mandates in Massachusetts, although you backed away from mandates on a national basis.
ROMNEY: No, no, I like mandates. The mandates work.
THOMPSON: I beg your pardon? I didn't know you were going to admit that. You like mandates.
ROMNEY: Let me -- let me -- oh, absolutely. Let me tell you what kind of mandates I like, Fred, which is this. If it weren't...
THOMPSON: The ones you come up with.
ROMNEY: Here's my view: If somebody -- if somebody can afford insurance and decides not to buy it, and then they get sick, they ought to pay their own way, as opposed to expect the government to pay their way. And that's an American principle. That's a principle of personal responsibility. So, I said this: If you can afford to buy insurance, then buy it. You don't have to, if you don't want to buy it, but then you got to put enough money aside that you can pay your own way, because what we're not going to do is say, as we saw more and more people...
THOMPSON: The government is going to make you buy insurance...
ROMNEY: No, the government is going to stop...
THOMPSON: ,.. and make you pay -- I mean, the state -- your state plan, which is, of course, different from your national plan, did require people to make that choice, though. The state required them to do that. What was the penalty if they refused?...
ROMNEY: ... It actually applies to people at three-times federal poverty. They pay for their own policy. At less than three-times federal poverty, we help them buy a policy, so everybody is insured, and everybody is able to buy a policy that is affordable for them. The question is this, again, if someone could afford a policy and they choose not to buy it, should they be responsible for paying for their own care? Or should they be able to go to the hospital and say, "You know what? I'm not insured. You ought to pay for it."
What we found was, one-quarter of the uninsured in my state were making $75,000 a year or more. And my view is they should either buy insurance or they should pay their own way with a health savings account or some other savings account.
... I think my plan is a good plan that should be adopted by other states.... I would not mandate at the federal level that every state do what we do. But what I would say at the federal level is, "We'll keep giving you these special payments we make if you adopt plans that get everybody insured." I want to get everybody insured....
HUCKABEE: I think it's important to realize that the issue is not just insurance. The issue is that the whole model of our health-care system is upside down. We really don't have a health-care system. We have a disease- care system. And the insurance model that we use, we act like that if we insured everybody, we've fixed it. We haven't. Because the real problem is that our model, both in the insurance model and the health-care model, waits until people are catastrophically ill before it intervenes. And we really have to change the concept to a preventive focus rather than an intervention focus. And that means the entire system starts working on health and wellness, because 80 percent of the $2 trillion that we spend on health care goes to chronic disease. We could prevent it or we could cure it, but we don't. So it's not an issue of there's not enough money to cover people. But if a real health care system exists, it has three components: It has affordability, it has quality, and it has accessibility.
And if it doesn't have those elements, it's not a system; it's a maze. And what we have in America is a health care maze. It's built on the idea that we wait until people are so desperately ill that the cost to try to fix them is catastrophic and out of control. And no wonder we have a system that needs major, major attention. And by the way, just out of due respect, you said $1,000 for a repair. It's about $1,000 for a Kleenex at a hospital anymore. And that's why we need to have a totally different system that keeps you from going to the hospital in the first place.
GIULIANI: Charlie, a health savings account actually helps to accomplish what the governor is talking about. If somebody can put aside -- and the plans that we've been talking about include a health savings account. You'd have an exemption up to $15,000. If you could find a policy for $11,000, you can have a $4,000 health savings account. You would be able to buy some of your health care and your prevention yourself. It gives you an incentive over a lifetime to deal with wellness.
GIBSON: ... Look, if you're going to control costs, you got to do three things. You're going to limit access to technology, you're going to limit, in some way, change the reimbursement system for doctors and hospitals, or you're going to have to limit the amount of treatments. That's the only way we can bring costs down. And that's the third rail of health care. Which of you is going to touch any of that?
HUCKABEE: Charlie, that's not at all the way it is...
MCCAIN: I think that there's additional choice here: a choice of having outcome-based treatment. There are five major diseases that consume 75 percent of health care costs in America. If someone has diabetes, we should give the health care provider a certain amount of money and say, "Care for that patient. And if, at the end of that period of time, and that patient is well, we'll give you a reward." Rather than every test, every procedure, every MRI. And we need walk-in clinics, and we need community health care, and we need incentives for home health care as opposed to long-term care. In my state of Arizona, we adopted a proposal which incentivizes health care providers to keep people in home health care settings -- dramatically less expensive than long-term care. In Arizona, we have one-half the number, per capita, of people in long-term care facilities as the state of Pennsylvania.
Incentives to keep costs down, Charlie. There are no incentives in the system today.
Could I just mention one other thing? Both the attorney general of South Carolina -- I don't know why I mention South Carolina... and the attorney general of Iowa ... have sued the pharmaceutical companies because of overcharging of millions of dollars of Medicaid costs to their patients. How could that happen? How could pharmaceutical companies be able to cover up the cost to the point where nobody knows? Why shouldn't we be able to reimport drugs from Canada? It's because of the power of the pharmaceutical companies. We should have pharmaceutical companies competing to take care of our Medicare and Medicaid patients.
ROMNEY: OK, don't leave me. Don't send the pharmaceutical companies into the big bad guys.
MCCAIN: Well, they are.
ROMNEY: No, actually they're trying to create products to make us well and make us better, and they're doing the work of the free market. And are there excesses? I'm sure there are, and we should go after excesses. But they're an important industry to this country. But let me note something else, and that is the market will work. And the reason health care isn't working like a market right now is you have 47 million people that are saying, "I'm not going to play. I'm just going to get free care paid for by everybody else." That doesn't work.
Number two, the buyer doesn't have information about what the cost or quality is, or different choices they could have. If you take the government out of it to a much greater extent, you'd get it to work like a market and it will rein in cost.
03 January 2008
Insurance Companies' Playbooks
A Cornell doc vents at the LA Times on Cigna's deadly tactics, denying care to its "consumers" until it's too late. This time it was leukemia patient Nataline Sarkisyan's liver transplant. Nataline, who was 17 when she died, was buried 28 December.
UCLA doctors had put her on a list for a liver transplant earlier in December, and a liver became available four days later. Her doctors told Cigna that Nataline had a 65% chance of living six months if she received a liver transplant. Cigna deemed the transplant experimental and refused to pay for it.
The California Nurses Assn., the Armenian community and Daily Kos publicized the case — which resulted in a telephone and e-mail campaign to urge Cigna to reconsider. It did, but too late for Nataline.
Giuseppe Del Priore has some details I didn't know about, such as the fact that denial of coverage always come with "a sentence to the effect that the doctors must provide whatever care is necessary and that the payment is a separate issue."
I agonize over having to choose whether to wait one more day for approval or to go ahead with the surgery and potentially damn the patient, his family, and the institution, to assuming the financial consequences. If I do go ahead without approval, no one comes to my defense when administrators ask me why so many of my patients' insurers are not paying. No one rescues the bankrupted families.Another nasty bit of work is calling procedures "experimental" in order to avoid paying for them. Nataline's procedure, he writes, wasn't experimental in any sense of the word.
Ironically, this puts the lie to the idea that American health care is so advanced. We predictably call procedures experimental that are routine in Europe.
Del Priore says the third insurance stall used to kill Nataline was the use of "expert" review — their bringing in what is little different than hired killers to deny care.
Insurers that review my denials define any has-been, retired, unemployed failure with a medical license an expert, paid to deny care. This is practicing medicine without examining the patient or seeing all the data. In effect, the licensed nurse or doctor working for an insurer is practicing medicine unprofessionally and criminally.
16 November 2007
Healthcare dragging down the economy
The Center for Economic and Policy Research has released "The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly: Job Quality in the United States over the Three Most Recent Business Cycles."
Killer title.
"This report finds that the US economy has created fewer good jobs in the 2000s than was the case over comparable periods in the 1980s and 1990s. The report analyzed annual data from the March Current Population Survey for the years 1979 through 2006 and shows that while the current business cycle has seen an increase in the share of jobs that pay at least $17 an hour, this gain has been more than offset by a decrease in the share of jobs that offer employer-provided health insurance (down 3.1 percent points) and pension coverage (down 4.9 percentage points)."
However, we're saved from being a nanny state. Good to look at the bright side, eh. Thanks be to all those Republicans and Dems who've made it possible.
Killer title.
"This report finds that the US economy has created fewer good jobs in the 2000s than was the case over comparable periods in the 1980s and 1990s. The report analyzed annual data from the March Current Population Survey for the years 1979 through 2006 and shows that while the current business cycle has seen an increase in the share of jobs that pay at least $17 an hour, this gain has been more than offset by a decrease in the share of jobs that offer employer-provided health insurance (down 3.1 percent points) and pension coverage (down 4.9 percentage points)."
However, we're saved from being a nanny state. Good to look at the bright side, eh. Thanks be to all those Republicans and Dems who've made it possible.
Labels:
Eat the Rich,
economics,
for-profit healthcare
15 September 2007
Healthcare in Norway for conservatives
Merete Cunningham, a Health Care for All Colorado supporter, wrote earlier this week for the Fort Collins, Colorado, Coloradan about single-payer healthcare in Norway. Despite the drums of fear from the right, it doesn't sound too scary.
She wrote, "My parents (my mother was a Conservative member of the Norwegian Parliament) lived and died under this system. As they grew old, I could not ask for more humane and decent treatment, at no cost to them, and without the need to sell off their assets. They were able to leave their estate to their heirs while living in a state-run facility. This is what I would like to see here, because I know that it is possible if the profit motive is removed.
"When a for-profit company in the United States is in charge of your health care insurance, company and health care goals must clash. A company's dedication to maximize profits is in direct opposition to its claim to provide health care for its members.... They are doing a great job for their shareholders. However, they are doing a horrible job of providing our health care. Nobody should profit from illness and death."
The first comment was an anti, ranting on about something about Lasik eye surgery. Thank God for Lasik eye surgery. If it weren't for Lasik the right would have nothing to point to as an example of why the free market will save medicine in the U.S.
Nothing.
She wrote, "My parents (my mother was a Conservative member of the Norwegian Parliament) lived and died under this system. As they grew old, I could not ask for more humane and decent treatment, at no cost to them, and without the need to sell off their assets. They were able to leave their estate to their heirs while living in a state-run facility. This is what I would like to see here, because I know that it is possible if the profit motive is removed.
"When a for-profit company in the United States is in charge of your health care insurance, company and health care goals must clash. A company's dedication to maximize profits is in direct opposition to its claim to provide health care for its members.... They are doing a great job for their shareholders. However, they are doing a horrible job of providing our health care. Nobody should profit from illness and death."
The first comment was an anti, ranting on about something about Lasik eye surgery. Thank God for Lasik eye surgery. If it weren't for Lasik the right would have nothing to point to as an example of why the free market will save medicine in the U.S.
Nothing.
09 January 2007
Today's health blog news
Kevin Drum comments, without enthusiasm, on Gov. Schwarzenegger plan for California healthcare reform. Drum admits his bias against any plan that cobbles together reforms but keeps the health insurance industry underpinning the system.
Here's his description of the plan:
"Basically, it's an individual mandate (i.e., everyone is required to buy health insurance, the same way everyone who drives is required to buy auto insurance) with state subsidies for those too poor to afford coverage. There's a new tax on doctors and hospitals, and small employers are required to either provide insurance for their employees or else pay a 4% payroll tax. Insurance companies, for their part, are required to offer insurance to everyone, regardless of medical history, age, or occupation (aka "community rating," meaning everyone in a particular community gets the same rate.)"
Drum says that Safeway execs have said it would be cheaper to pay the 4 percent payroll tax than to continue to pay the 7 percent that health insurance costs them.
This is exactly why keeping the insurance industry in the game won't fly. They're too expensive a price to pay just to satisfy ideology.
Read the whole post regarding Schwwarzenegger's plan.
Ezra Klein links to Over My Med Body, which has a list today of 50 conditions that can cause insurers to reject you. Including allergies, bed wetting, breast implants, impotence, working with chemicals, roofing, lumber work, window-washing and war reporting. How does that serve our economy, not to insure those folks?
Klein also has an post about mandated insurance, such as Schwarzenegger proposed for California yesterday. Klein says he's heard criticism that such a system "criminalizes the uninsured," evidently from single-payer advocates, and he notes that single-payer is also mandated insurance. His criticism seems to be that single-payer advocates are complaining about government coercion when single-payer would also coerce: force people to have health insurance via their taxes.
Klein seems to think that as long as government subsidizes the private, for-profit system — up to 400 percent of poverty with Sen. Wyden's proposed plan and up to 300 percent in Massachusetts, that such a system would be fine. The Schwarzenegger proposal only subsidizes up to 250 percent; not enough in Klein's view.
This entire avenue of reform proposes wasting our dollars in order to continue a wasteful system. The problem with mandated insurance as in Massachusetts or Schwarzenegger's proposal isn't the mandate, it's what it's for: subsidizing an inefficient system with poor quality built in because of its fragmented structure. It's going to continue to be a drag on our economy as a whole and on our individual households. But yes, better than what we have now.
Andrew Sullivan provides a great link to Psychology Today Magazine and an article on ideology and fear:
"We tend to believe our political views have evolved by a process of rational thought, as we consider arguments, weigh evidence, and draw conclusions... Among the most potent motivators, it turns out, is fear... The fear of death alone is surprisingly effective in shaping our political decisions—more powerful, often, than thought itself."
This is potent. The powerful pharmaceutical/health insurance/for-profit medical industry counts on it. We on the side of the angels need to do a better job of understanding it.
Health Affairs blog reminds us that New York's Elliot Spitzer also is moving to reform that state's healthcare system. Or not — maybe he's just going to tinker with it, as in Massachusetts and along the lines of Schwarzenegger.
The top 25 articles from 2006 are available online free at Health Affairs until January 19. Go to the blog for that link.
Health Care Renewal has a post from Sunday about MBA-think screwing up all kinds of businesses, with the idea that every business is basically the same.
There's been a lot of news about Home Depot's CEO retiring after six years with a $210 million golden parachute, but Health Care Renewal points out that Pfizer's CEO got an even bigger package after being forced out after Pfizer's stock took an even bigger hit than Home Depots.
"So we see hospitals with fewer nurses, primary care physicians over-worked, under-paid, demoralized, and threatened with replacement by nurses and physicians' assistants, and the hiring of drug representatives not with pharmacology doctorates, but with experience as cheer-leaders. (Meanwhile, we see hospital, managed care, and pharmaceutical executives, many with little previous experience in actually providing health care, clinical research, or making pharmaceuticals, hauling in ever higher compensation.)"
Here's his description of the plan:
"Basically, it's an individual mandate (i.e., everyone is required to buy health insurance, the same way everyone who drives is required to buy auto insurance) with state subsidies for those too poor to afford coverage. There's a new tax on doctors and hospitals, and small employers are required to either provide insurance for their employees or else pay a 4% payroll tax. Insurance companies, for their part, are required to offer insurance to everyone, regardless of medical history, age, or occupation (aka "community rating," meaning everyone in a particular community gets the same rate.)"
Drum says that Safeway execs have said it would be cheaper to pay the 4 percent payroll tax than to continue to pay the 7 percent that health insurance costs them.
This is exactly why keeping the insurance industry in the game won't fly. They're too expensive a price to pay just to satisfy ideology.
Read the whole post regarding Schwwarzenegger's plan.
Ezra Klein links to Over My Med Body, which has a list today of 50 conditions that can cause insurers to reject you. Including allergies, bed wetting, breast implants, impotence, working with chemicals, roofing, lumber work, window-washing and war reporting. How does that serve our economy, not to insure those folks?
Klein also has an post about mandated insurance, such as Schwarzenegger proposed for California yesterday. Klein says he's heard criticism that such a system "criminalizes the uninsured," evidently from single-payer advocates, and he notes that single-payer is also mandated insurance. His criticism seems to be that single-payer advocates are complaining about government coercion when single-payer would also coerce: force people to have health insurance via their taxes.
Klein seems to think that as long as government subsidizes the private, for-profit system — up to 400 percent of poverty with Sen. Wyden's proposed plan and up to 300 percent in Massachusetts, that such a system would be fine. The Schwarzenegger proposal only subsidizes up to 250 percent; not enough in Klein's view.
This entire avenue of reform proposes wasting our dollars in order to continue a wasteful system. The problem with mandated insurance as in Massachusetts or Schwarzenegger's proposal isn't the mandate, it's what it's for: subsidizing an inefficient system with poor quality built in because of its fragmented structure. It's going to continue to be a drag on our economy as a whole and on our individual households. But yes, better than what we have now.
Andrew Sullivan provides a great link to Psychology Today Magazine and an article on ideology and fear:
"We tend to believe our political views have evolved by a process of rational thought, as we consider arguments, weigh evidence, and draw conclusions... Among the most potent motivators, it turns out, is fear... The fear of death alone is surprisingly effective in shaping our political decisions—more powerful, often, than thought itself."
This is potent. The powerful pharmaceutical/health insurance/for-profit medical industry counts on it. We on the side of the angels need to do a better job of understanding it.
Health Affairs blog reminds us that New York's Elliot Spitzer also is moving to reform that state's healthcare system. Or not — maybe he's just going to tinker with it, as in Massachusetts and along the lines of Schwarzenegger.
The top 25 articles from 2006 are available online free at Health Affairs until January 19. Go to the blog for that link.
Health Care Renewal has a post from Sunday about MBA-think screwing up all kinds of businesses, with the idea that every business is basically the same.
There's been a lot of news about Home Depot's CEO retiring after six years with a $210 million golden parachute, but Health Care Renewal points out that Pfizer's CEO got an even bigger package after being forced out after Pfizer's stock took an even bigger hit than Home Depots.
"So we see hospitals with fewer nurses, primary care physicians over-worked, under-paid, demoralized, and threatened with replacement by nurses and physicians' assistants, and the hiring of drug representatives not with pharmacology doctorates, but with experience as cheer-leaders. (Meanwhile, we see hospital, managed care, and pharmaceutical executives, many with little previous experience in actually providing health care, clinical research, or making pharmaceuticals, hauling in ever higher compensation.)"
05 January 2007
Check out Les Enragés.org
Take a look at Les Enragés, where "Sad But True" encouraged me to post the story of Paul's death. He did a great job of editing and hand-holding for this neophyte blogger.
Paul's story ended up there because it paralleled that of Sad But True's best friend — a Canadian man who is still alive gratis the Canadian single-payer system. As I believe Paul would be as well had he lived in Canada rather than California.
The difference being that Sad But True's friend went straight-away to the hospital, without worrying if it would bankrupt him. The difference being that the Canadian hospital didn't send that guy away, but instead cared for him.
The difference being that the Canadian hospital took immediate action when it was clear that there was something wrong, rather than dithering about getting the guy to a charity hospital.
I discovered the Les Enragés site via Crooks & Liars, which also linked to Bob Geiger's story. Geiger writes about his brain surgery for acute subdural hematoma — a bunch of blood in his brain. His surgery went well, but during his recovery a conversation with a nurse stuck with him.
"'Do people still die from a subdural hematoma?' I asked one of the nurses, while still in my ICU bed. 'Yes,' she replied. 'Just not people like you.' When pressed for what she meant by that statement, she said 'People with good health insurance, who can afford a neurosurgeon from Scarsdale don't die from these as much.'
As Geiger looked into it, he found that "a large number of people do indeed still die from the inability to easily obtain a 20-minute surgery, a procedure that has become a simple, routine operation for all neurosurgeons."
He began thinking about it: "I'm inherently worth no more as a person than any other husband, father and friend and yet, in the case of a medical crisis like mine -- and more recently, South Dakota Senator Tim Johnson's condition -- the ready accessibility of an emergency procedure can be the difference between life and death," he wrote.
"In one of the richest countries in the world, death should not be the penalty for having no health insurance. Yet, 47 million Americans still have no basic coverage and too many of those would die for lack of the same short procedure I so easily received."
I believe that most Americans have those same values — good values that should be easy to make reality, because doing the right thing, in this case, is also doing the cost-effective thing that benefits everyone.
Ah. Except for the people who are making really big money from the status quo.
And their dollars are able to create advertising that scares the bejeezus out of people. Rationing! Waiting lists! Socialized medicine!
But the reality is that it could be that enough people understand that what we have right now is what's scary. Not the change to a single-payer system, think of it as Medicare for All, where you choose your doctor; you and your doctor choose your hospital, should that become necessary; and the government picks up the tab. And it costs less than what we have right now.
The crazy thing is that so many people believe that cutting taxes doesn't result in deficits — despite that happening every time — but those same folks don't believe that expanding Medicare to all could save money. Despite the fact that every other developed country in the world has universal health care and pays less per capita than we do.

Who are we going to believe? Our lying eyes or William McGuire and the insurance industry? Our United Healthcare premiums allowed McGuire, former CEO of United Healthcare, to retire last year with $1.8 billion in back-dated stock options.
Paul becomes nothing more than collateral damage for a guy like this.
Paul's story ended up there because it paralleled that of Sad But True's best friend — a Canadian man who is still alive gratis the Canadian single-payer system. As I believe Paul would be as well had he lived in Canada rather than California.
The difference being that Sad But True's friend went straight-away to the hospital, without worrying if it would bankrupt him. The difference being that the Canadian hospital didn't send that guy away, but instead cared for him.
The difference being that the Canadian hospital took immediate action when it was clear that there was something wrong, rather than dithering about getting the guy to a charity hospital.
I discovered the Les Enragés site via Crooks & Liars, which also linked to Bob Geiger's story. Geiger writes about his brain surgery for acute subdural hematoma — a bunch of blood in his brain. His surgery went well, but during his recovery a conversation with a nurse stuck with him.
"'Do people still die from a subdural hematoma?' I asked one of the nurses, while still in my ICU bed. 'Yes,' she replied. 'Just not people like you.' When pressed for what she meant by that statement, she said 'People with good health insurance, who can afford a neurosurgeon from Scarsdale don't die from these as much.'
As Geiger looked into it, he found that "a large number of people do indeed still die from the inability to easily obtain a 20-minute surgery, a procedure that has become a simple, routine operation for all neurosurgeons."
He began thinking about it: "I'm inherently worth no more as a person than any other husband, father and friend and yet, in the case of a medical crisis like mine -- and more recently, South Dakota Senator Tim Johnson's condition -- the ready accessibility of an emergency procedure can be the difference between life and death," he wrote.
"In one of the richest countries in the world, death should not be the penalty for having no health insurance. Yet, 47 million Americans still have no basic coverage and too many of those would die for lack of the same short procedure I so easily received."
I believe that most Americans have those same values — good values that should be easy to make reality, because doing the right thing, in this case, is also doing the cost-effective thing that benefits everyone.
Ah. Except for the people who are making really big money from the status quo.
And their dollars are able to create advertising that scares the bejeezus out of people. Rationing! Waiting lists! Socialized medicine!
But the reality is that it could be that enough people understand that what we have right now is what's scary. Not the change to a single-payer system, think of it as Medicare for All, where you choose your doctor; you and your doctor choose your hospital, should that become necessary; and the government picks up the tab. And it costs less than what we have right now.
The crazy thing is that so many people believe that cutting taxes doesn't result in deficits — despite that happening every time — but those same folks don't believe that expanding Medicare to all could save money. Despite the fact that every other developed country in the world has universal health care and pays less per capita than we do.

Who are we going to believe? Our lying eyes or William McGuire and the insurance industry? Our United Healthcare premiums allowed McGuire, former CEO of United Healthcare, to retire last year with $1.8 billion in back-dated stock options.
Paul becomes nothing more than collateral damage for a guy like this.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


